On this page Jump to section
Define an authorized spot check
A spot check can reveal whether journal-entry documentation is easy to reconstruct. It is not an audit opinion and does not establish that all entries are correct. The accounting owner should define the purpose, permitted access, population and review criteria before the assistant collects any records.
The title's “surprise” should mean that the review is not limited to a preselected showcase of tidy examples. It should not mean secret access, bypassed permissions or an attempt to catch colleagues without an agreed process. Use the organization's approved review procedure and communicate findings through the designated owner.
Preserve the population before selecting records
Record the entity, date range, source report, extraction date and filters. Retain the original population in approved storage. If the population changes during review, preserve the first version and explain whether the owner wants the sample refreshed.
Ask the owner to approve the selection method. Do not describe a convenience sample as representative of all entries. A review of a few selected records can identify questions about those records, but it cannot by itself establish a population-wide error rate or the absence of problems elsewhere.
Check the documentation against agreed criteria
- Entry identity
- CollectThe entry reference, entity, date and source location.
- CheckThe record matches the selected item and reporting scope.
- Supporting evidence
- CollectThe documents or calculations identified by the accounting owner.
- CheckRequired sources are present, readable and tied to this entry.
- Purpose
- CollectThe documented explanation and its author.
- CheckThe explanation can be located without reconstructing an informal conversation.
- Approval
- CollectThe required review record and decision date.
- CheckThe approval applies to the same version and scope.
- Open question
- CollectThe exact missing or conflicting item and next reviewer.
- CheckThe observation is not presented as an accounting conclusion.
Example: support exists, but the version does not match
The selected entry links to a calculation that was revised after the recorded approval. The assistant notes the two version dates and asks the reviewer whether the approved calculation can be located or whether further review is needed. They preserve both documents and the original approval reference.
This observation does not establish that the entry is wrong. It identifies a documentation question requiring an authorized decision. The assistant does not alter the entry, recreate an approval or overwrite the earlier calculation to make the packet appear complete.
Report coverage and exceptions honestly
State how many records were selected, how many were reviewed and which could not be accessed. List exceptions with source references, next owners and response dates. Keep missing documentation separate from conflicting documentation and from accounting questions outside the assistant's scope.
If the owner expands the review, retain the initial sample and add the expanded scope as a new stage. Do not replace failed examples with cleaner ones merely to finish the check. A transparent record of limitations is more useful than an unsupported “all clear.”
Close the administrative review
Link each response to its original exception and preserve unresolved items in the handoff. The accounting owner decides whether additional work or corrections are required. Completion of evidence collection does not authorize journal entries or certify the books.
See reporting preparation support for document organization and reviewer follow-up within an agreed scope.
Related resources
Compare the service fit on the QuickBooks VA services page, then use the free consultation form to map the first handoff. For platform context, review QuickBooks Online.
